Text Preview. Question: How did Bianca become the shrew at the end of Shakespeare's "The Taming of the Shrew"? With either interpretation of Katherine’s final speech the overall message of the play is affected. I bet you can’t get her to change, well watch me. Katherina is a very different main character than most of Shakespeare’s heroines. In contrast, Kate does not believe that he feels the same way towards her. This Shakespeare play is not often touted as a favorite. The Taming of the Shrew is an early Shakespeare comedy, believed to have been written between 1590 and 1592. Charles Robert Leslie (1794–1859), via Wikimedia Commons. His "friend" Hortensio adored Katharina's sister Bianca, but they could not marry until Katherina was married, therefore, Hortensio tried to convince Petruchio to marry Katharina. She was spoiled and was used to getting her way. Angela Michelle Schultz (author) from United States on March 07, 2010: I am careful to use the word submit, because there is a duality that is going on. He convinces her father that they are madly in love despite Kate's dislike of him. Submitting is not the same as obeying. Later she uses further piercing words, such as “foul contending rebel” and “graceless traitor,” which again are not met with an immediate challenge (V.ii.165-166). Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Question: Why does Katherine let herself be tamed in the Taming of the Shrew? Widely reputed throughout Padua to be a shrew, Katherine is foul-tempered and sharp-tongued at the start of the play. Her spoiled tendencies did not shine through until the end, as we see the contrast of Kate's transformation and Bianca's normal state. According to this reading, Kate's subjection is a form of grand sarcasm, as she pretends to genuflect before the childish men who have spent so much of the play in comic confusion. Question: What was Kate and Petruchio's connection during their first encounter in "Taming of the Shrew"? You can use a text widget to display text, links, images, HTML, or a combination of these. Edit them in the Widget section of the, Blog #4: Interpretation of Kates Final Speech in The Taming of the Shrew, Blog #5 – Merchant of Venice and the Gender Relations Surrounding Marriage, Antiquated Social Norms in Taming of the Shrew. Despite Petruchio’s criticism of the meat, she insists that it is okay. Posted on June 2, 2014 by sammironko. The last part of her description shows the sincerity in what she is saying. She is a strong person, which attracts Petruchio. You did a wonderful job with it. It is, for obvious reasons, abhorrent to many feminist critics, who take issue with Kate’s recommendation of total subservience to the husband—she says at different points that the man is the woman’s lord, king, governor, life, keeper, head, and sovereign. We’ll stick with Katherine because that’s the name she seems to prefer. ( Log Out / But instead, she made a show of the nonsensicalness. “Woman are bound to obey because.” “You frower and unable worms.” She is basically saying that she is not a shrew anymore and has succumb to her husband. The Different Ways to Tame a Shrew in Kiss Me Kate and The Taming of the Shrew 1192 Words | 5 Pages. Analysis of Kate’s speech Shakespeare was mostly interested in the concept that life imitated art. She constantly insults and degrades the men around her, and she is prone to wild displays of anger, during which she may physically attack whomever enrages her. Kate is reluctant, Petruchio threatens that they'll leave town, and Kate explains that she's just embarrassed, being in the street. Petruchio will merely say the opposite of whatever Katherine says in order to exhaust her ill-tempered ways. I personally believe that yes, we should definitely study this play as it helps give insight into the past. Kate voices these feelings when she snaps at her father as he comes to Bianca’s defense by saying, “[Bianca] is your treasure” (II.i.32), which reflects Kate’s belief that her father views Bianca as someone valuable. If she had meant it to be sarcastic, this admission of being cared for would seem out of place and misguided. Petruchio wanted to show Kate how mean she was, by beating her at her own game. The immaturity of this act reflects her lacking the basic necessity of being nurtured and feeling cared for. Answer: Honestly, I believe she always was. Children should obey their parents. This affectionate term further signifies that she has fallen in love with Petruchio. I love this play and have seen it several times in several different performances! The fact that neither her sister nor the widow immediately argue back is a reflection of Kate’s continuing authoritative demeanor. ...The Taming of the Shrew: Kate's Soliloquy Kate's soliloquy bring about a joyous conclusion to The Taming of the Shrew. As far as obeying, he also would not expect her to obey anything that was not in her best interest. However, Katherine's sincerity in this transformation is debatable, and one could argue (as some productions of the play present it) that Katherine is merely pretending to submit to Petruchio and that her final speech is so over the top that it becomes sarcastic and a parody of wifely obedience. Underlying the speech is Kate's awareness that she is in a partnership and that by advancing the power of her husband she advances her own power. It is not Gremio or any other suitor that Kate feels jealousy towards; she feels jealous of Bianca and how everyone, even their father, views her as the preferred sister. It has lasted many years, and is still as great as the original. Then again, in her final speech, Kate talks at length with a strong presence that captivates her audience, further proving she is still the feisty woman she had been at the very beginning but with new understanding. It concerns a number of men who are trying to win the heart of a beautiful young maiden, unfortunately she can only be … If she’s being sincere, it’s because she’s been forced to. If she had not wanted to marry him, she would have thrown the same kind of fit as she was accustomed to prior. The audience leaves the theatre with a pleasant feeling, glad that such a shrew could be tamed so well. Kate’s speech at the end of the play has been the focus of many interpretations. Bianca wanted to get married. I think if a man is truly loving his wife as Jesus loved the church, then her best interest would always be in the forefront of his mind; therefore, he would not just expect her to serve him solely, but take care of herself as well. Biondello is Lucentio's servant. This is the best analysis I've seen; everyone today seems to be worried about offending others, while this simple takes into account what the script actually says in full, not in part. Answer: They both were very quick-witted and intelligent. Her speech at the end is over the top and is often thought to be mocking and sarcastic. The first three things reflect the views of marriage in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Many people get stuck on the Bible stating that a woman is supposed to submit to their husband and miss the rest of that verse where it states that a man should love the wife as Christ loves the church. In the play, Petruchio, who is the main character, tames Kate, the daughter of a rich man, in hopes of having her to wed so that he may collect her father’s dowry. Taming the Shrew I think the play is a good example that we have to first love ourselves for who we are (rather than becoming a narcissist). One of the best scenes to reflect this would be before Kate’s arrival at her father’s house as Petruchio and her are on their walk. As her awareness of others grows, so does her ability to show love. For instance, once the marriage ceremony ends, she desires to stay for the reception, whereas Petruchio wants to leave. contending rebel". Voted up for useful! Taming Of The Shrew Film Analysis. Taming of the Shrew has been read and reread, performed, and reperformed. Even the wedding guests can't believe how much her behavior has changed. Most of the characters are in disguise, and play a role within a role. She uses the expression “God forbid,” which emphasizes her feelings against being ashamed of him. Later in the same scene, the playfulness is further shown as they approach Lucentia’s father. Taming of the (right) Shrew analysis” The play “Taming of the Shrew” by Shakespeare, introduces several themes, among them the theme of disguise.Most of the characters are in disguise, and play a role within a role. Answer: Keep in mind that Petruchio wanted to marry a wealthy woman. If this is not evidenced enough, you see her still argumentative nature when she says, “And so it shall be still for Katherine” (V.i.22). the key in understanding this is in the antithesis of her conditions. “The Taming of the Shrew.” However, she does it with tact and poise, which is no longer met with a dispute. With a literal interpretation, such as mine, The Taming of the Shrew is a bitterly misogynistic play about a cruel man who spiritually beats and starves his wife into subservience. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Katherine Monologue Analysis (From: The Taming of the Shrew) Posted on June 1, 2014 by faeryspawn In the play, The Taming of the Shrew , written by William Shakespeare; the lead Character, Katherine Baptista says a final monologue which, in my opinion, sums up the entirety of her views of the last few months of her life. Congrats your Hub of the Day award for an interesting post filled with food for thought. It takes a strong and beautiful woman to be able to submit to her rightful head, because she has to learn to serve, to obey, and to look to another's needs more than her own. Regardless, this is the first time she hears such flatteries as being called as “sweet as springtime flowers” (II.i.247) or being told “thy beauty that doth make me like thee well” (II.i.275) then eventually requesting her hand in marriage. Few women, now and especially during Shakespeare’s time, would be willing to risk humiliation for themselves or others, unless they have a strong personality. This refers to what men of this time had to do for their wives. In this speech, Katherina is speaking to her sister Bianca, who has recently married Lucentio, and the new wife of Hortensio. Mary Norton from Ontario, Canada on June 22, 2015: You have done an excellent job on this review. It’s Kate’s desire for love with Petruchio’s help that leads her to show love and empathy without losing her feisty attitude. She is known throughout the town for her angry abrasive manner. Katherine’s speech can be interpreted depending on how you look at it. We know that Kate has outwardly transformed by the time she finishes her lengthy monologue about a wife's duty to her husband. Do you have a degree in English literature. Below you can explore Katherina’s speech at the end of Act 5 Scene 1. Congrats on HOTD, too! But you would have to work hard to get that to work, because the text to me says that she’s saying I don’t have my own character anymore, my thoughts and ideas are my husbands. This admission goes further than just recognition of a husband’s willingness to work hard and to provide for his wife; she also claims that her desire to be submissive and loving is “too little payment for so great a debt” (V.ii.160). Character Analysis Of Kate In Taming Of The Shrew. In the next line, Kate again proves her growing love for him. I will be having my high school students read it as an example of an effective analysis. That being said, humans love to watch Home Alone and laugh at the cruel treatment of the two thieves, so it was intended to bring humor by being way over the top. Women are allowed to disagree with their husband. This speech addresses his absurdity by saying, “But sun it is not when you say it is not, / And the moon changes even as your mind” (V.i.20-21). Taming of the Shrew Essay May 31, 2014. This question is much like what a child would ask their mother or best friend. Question: What do you think is the main moral of the story? Rather, her final speech is a hostile negotiation in which failure to agree results in a loss of face, reputation and money on Petruchio's part. II Features of patriarchal society Women have long been treated as men’s property and have also been deprived of the right to pursue freedom. Petruchio calls her ‘bonny Kate’, ‘the prettiest Kate in Christendom’, ‘Kate of Kate Hall’ and even ‘super dainty Kate’. ( Log Out / If you’re looking at it textually based, she’s a beaten down woman who is being sincere only because she has no choice and has been pidgin holed into do this or you’ll regret it. The situation has been "miraculously transformed." Katherine’s speech can be interpreted depending on how you look at it. Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. I've been teaching taming of the Shrew for decades and have come to the position that Kate's speech is the third of a series of contracts in the play, the first two being the covenant between Petruchio and Baptista, while the second is the fraudulent contract with the supposed Vincentio. Through her word choices, one can see that she has indeed fallen in love with Petruchio. She tells the wives, "Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper, / … Now, pray thee, love, stay” (V.ii.139). Though this farce has always been a popular one, it isn’t without controversy. Question: Is it a possibility that Kate from Shakespeare's "The Taming of the Shrew" is putting on a complying act because she knows that by pretending to submit, she can get what she wants? She could play it beaten down, like “I tried but woman can’t be more than this.” She could be sarcastic but Petruchio would probably slap her if she was. She shows this by explaining this behavior through a husband’s eyes. “Taming of the (right) Shrew analysis” The play “Taming of the Shrew” by Shakespeare, introduces several themes, among them the theme of disguise. That is essentially saying that a man should lay his life down figuratively and literally for his wife. They are allowed to bring up their concerns, but they should do so in a respectful way. This transformation is due to Petruchio’s over-the-top kindness towards Kate and cruelty towards all others. Petruchio beckons a kiss. The fact that she is willing to go along with his outlandish remarks and humiliate a man she has never met proves she has not lost her spunk. Analysis of Kate’s speech Shakespeare was mostly interested in the concept that life imitated art. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Taming Of The Shrew Analysis 927 Words | 4 Pages ‘The Taming of the Shrew’ is a play written in 1593 by famous playwright William Shakespeare. Kate still is able and willing to fight, which is apparent in her monologue. Then when Petruchio arrives, Kate finally finds someone who gives her compliments. While in this society, a woman is asked to be obedient, it is not without men serving women as well. Answer: I believe the moral of the story is to about true character. During this scene, she begins chiding the two women about their childish behavior towards their husbands. Angela Michelle Schultz (author) from United States on January 25, 2017: Thank you very much. See if you can notice the things Mark tells us to look out for: Imagery; Metre; Word choice If I were theoretically directing the show and didn’t want to make Katherine a story of a fallen strong woman, then you could say this was her idea all along and this is what she wanted, so instead of Petruchio taking a wager and taming Kate, you could flip it on its head and say Kate is the mastermind taming Petruchio to be a good husband. This statement is also significant because it expresses her sincerity towards Petruchio as a husband. Her quarrelsome behavior is not entirely due to her lack of being loved, but also her self-absorption. She has a passion for the written word and loves literature. So in the end, Kate has not either been tamed, nor has has simply told Petruchio what he wanted to hear. Sulabha Dhavalikar from Indore, India on June 22, 2015: You are simply brilliant. Kate rightly represents such an alternative to defy Petruchio. She rebukes, yet no one interrupts. If he is dishonest, then her rebellion becomes patriotic since the contract has become essentially null and void. The book is a comedy, mainly about Petruchio and his wife Kate. Just as the word “love” is chosen, her word choices in the final speech prove she is genuinely in love with Petruchio and sincere in what she says to the two women. Kate’s willingness to kiss Petruchio is more than just a desire to stay at her father’s house; her word choice proves this, which she reveals when she calls him “love,” before she kisses him. His response is, wow there’s a winch come kiss me. Now, pray thee, love, stay” (V.ii.139). She is capable of being a submissive wife but be her own person, as well. In the Taming of the Shrew, the themes of illusion versus reality, classstruggles, male-female relationships, and transformationare reflected in both the introduction framework and the play within the play. Blogging about topics regarding a 52 year old man who may or may not have written literary brilliance 400+ years ago, and the link between said literary brilliance and the adaptations of his" work performed on both stage and in film. She is talking amongst both men and women, yet all listen. Kate recognizes that her husband is working hard for her to have food on the table and a safe home. When she refuses the first time, he asks if it’s because she is embarrassed of him. In one sense, she is hungry and will say anything to be allowed to eat the meat, regardless of its state.
Ophtalmologue Le Puy En Velay, Singapore Covid Vaccine Sinovac, Does Distrokid Distribute To Boomplay, La Bible 01 Episode, Scottish Open Courses, Azeip Phone Number, Tf2 Pugs Discord, What Is High Default Probability In Stock, Braeden Campbell Wiki,